Steward case

CASE-002555

Two plausible identities score within 0.1 of each other (0.81 vs 0.79).

OpenCheckpointckpt-run-mvfoap9e-73374workflow paused, state held

Side-by-side comparison

Incoming CLM-424275 against 3 candidate identities, green agrees, red conflicts, raw bronze value shown beneath when normalisation changed it

Field	CLMCLM-424275incoming	#1MBR-041747Charles Murray 0.811 rec. Best evidence: NameAddress	#2MBR-012866Charles Murray 0.795 rec. Best evidence: NameDate of birthPhone	#3MBR-030202Amy Murray 0.651 rec. Best evidence: none ≥ 0.90
Name	Charlees Murray	Charles Murray	Charles P Murray	Amy Murray
Date of birth	1952-01-15	1951-01-15	1952-01-15	1952-03-15
Member ID	— UNKNOWN	—	UHC-35400-66	—
SSN	•••-••-3224	—	•••-••-3224	—
Phone	6703295030 670-329-5030	—	6703295030	—
Email	— NULL	charles.murray@icloud.com	charles.murray@icloud.com	—
Address	5473 Mesa Dr 5473 MESA DRIVE	5473 Mesa Dr # 768	8544 Apache Blvd	—
City / state / ZIP	San Diego, CA, 92199 San Diego, CA , 92199	San Diego, CA, 92199	Nashville, TN, 37208	—
Group	—	GRP-6232	GRP-6232	—
Plan	CHOICE-PLUS-PPO	SELECT-EPO	CHOICE-PLUS-PPO	MEDICARE-ADV-B
Sources, records	CLM1 record	TPA ×11 record	ENR ×1PRV ×2TPA ×1CLM ×15 records	TPA ×11 record

Evidence detail

How the scoring agent compared the incoming record to the record it matched inside each candidate

▶#1MBR-041747Charles Murray0.81

Matched against TPA-60699, 3 fields compared, weighted score 0.809

Field	Similarity	Weight	Share	Note
Name	0.99	3	38%
Date of birth	0.50	3	38%	one_digit
Address	1.00	2	25%	exact

Guard: noneConflicts: none

Records in this identity

TPATPA-60699Charles Murray1951-01-15Single record 1.00

▶#2MBR-012866Charles Murray0.79

Matched against ENR-131733, 4 fields compared, weighted score 0.786

Field	Similarity	Weight	Share	Note
Name	0.99	3	32%
Date of birth	1.00	3	32%	exact
Phone	1.00	1.5	16%
Address	0.00	2	21%	different

Guard: noneConflicts: none

Records in this identity

ENRENR-131733Charles Murray1952-01-15Scored 1.00
PRVPRV-27151Charles Murray1952-01-15Scored 1.00
PRVPRV-27150Charles Murray1952-01-15Scored 1.00
TPATPA-60700Charlie Murray1952-10-15Scored 0.87
CLMCLM-424274Charles Murraay1952-01-15Scored 0.99

▶#3MBR-030202Amy Murray0.65

Matched against TPA-51136, 2 fields compared, weighted score 0.647

Field	Similarity	Weight	Share	Note
Name	0.79	3	50%
Date of birth	0.50	3	50%	one_digit

Guard: noneConflicts: none

Records in this identity

TPATPA-51136Amy Murray1952-03-15Single record 1.00

Case audit

Every transition on this case, sealed into the hash chain

Steward case openedEscalation agent2026-10-19 19:54:3970ace35057
Escalated CLM-424275, top score 0.81, candidates MBR-041747, MBR-012866, MBR-030202

AI recommendation

Advisory only; the steward decides

The model can read the same side-by-side evidence and suggest link, new or reject with a rationale. It never decides.

Steward decision

Recording a decision resumes the paused workflow and updates the graph immediately

Decision

Link to Charles MurrayMBR-041747, score 0.81, 1 recordLinkLink to Charles MurrayMBR-012866, score 0.79, 5 recordsLinkLink to Amy MurrayMBR-030202, score 0.65, 1 recordLinkConfirm as a distinct identityCLM-424275 stays on its own golden identity, marked verified.New identityReject record (quarantine)The record's identity is quarantined; nothing downstream may act on it.Reject

Rationale *

At least 8 characters (0/8)

ActorJ. Okafor (Data Stewardship)

Choose an option

Checkpoint: ckpt-run-mvfoap9e-73374
Stage: Human steward
Policy version: v1, threshold 0.85, floor 0.6
Provisional identity: MBR-040533
Opened: 2026-10-19 19:54:36
Top score: 0.81